Best Overall
KBDiy Carbon 174-Key Set
Key details
- Profile
- Cherry, R1 to R4
- Key Count
- 174 keys (128 base + 46 supplementary)
- Legend Method
- Double-shot PBT
- Layout Coverage
- ANSI/ISO, 60% to 100%
A hundred and seventy-four caps arrive in this box, and the split is the interesting part: 128 base keys and 46 supplementary ones. That second bag is what lets a single set cover 60% boards through full-size, ANSI and ISO layouts, without you ordering an add-on kit afterward. If you own a 96% or an ISO board and have been quietly making do with a right Shift that does not match, this is the set that ends the compromise.
Coverage alone does not earn a top spot — plenty of big kits fit badly. What settled it for us is that this is a proper Cherry sculpt, row by row from R1 to R4, in double-shot PBT. The caps sit low and angled the way most of us expect a good keyboard to feel, and the plastic has the dry, faintly grainy surface that stops your fingertips skating. Double-shot legends run through the cap instead of sitting on it, so the letters will not rub away where your thumbs live.
The feel is what kept bringing us back. These walls are thick enough to give a low, clacky note instead of the hollow tick thin stock caps make, and the stems grip firmly without a fight. The finish has stayed matte on the keys we hit hardest, which is more than the ABS caps on most gaming boards manage.
Color is the other half of the decision, and this is not a shy set: three colorways, with the orange-and-carbon scheme doing most of the talking. Want your keyboard to read as a tool rather than a statement? Pick one of the plainer options. Either way the 174 caps and the low Cherry sculpt are identical, and that is the part you will still care about long after the novelty of a new color wears off.
Pros
- 174 keys cover ANSI, ISO, and 60% to full-size boards
- Low Cherry sculpt with a dry, grippy texture
- Thick double-shot walls give a deep, clacky sound
- Stems seat firmly without needing force
Cons
- Legend weight varies between rows
- Spacebars do not seat on every stabilizer layout
We recommend the KBDiy set to anyone with an awkward layout: 174 double-shot PBT caps in a low Cherry sculpt, and the widest coverage in this group.