Best Overall
8BitDo Retro 18
Key details
- Keys
- 18
- Weight
- 1.3 lb
- Switches
- Kailh Box White V2
- Connection
- Bluetooth, 2.4G, USB
The Retro 18 has something the rest of these don't: put it in calculator mode and it does the arithmetic itself on a small red display, with no computer involved. We expected a novelty and got something we reach for whenever a total needs checking without losing your place in the invoice on screen.
Connection is where it earns the top spot. Bluetooth for a laptop, the 2.4 GHz dongle for a desktop that never moves, and USB-C when the battery runs down — switching between them is a key combination rather than a trip behind the tower. If you work across two machines in a day, that flexibility stops being a bullet point and starts being the reason you bought it.
The Kailh Box White switches are the loud, crisp kind, with a click you'll either love or apologize for. There's real weight here at 1.3 pounds, and it sits still on its feet while you type fast. The plus key is a little narrower than the one on a full-size keyboard, which we noticed for about two days before our fingers adjusted.
Where it gives ground is software. The keys aren't remappable, so a macro column or a key that pastes values isn't on the menu, and Mac users should go straight to the Satechi since this one is Windows and Android only. Everything else holds up — and because the calculator runs on its own, it's the only pad here still useful when the laptop is asleep.
Pros
- Three connection modes, including a 2.4 GHz dongle
- Standalone calculator mode works with no host
- Heavy, stable case with crisp Kailh Box White switches
Cons
- Not programmable
- Windows and Android only; no macOS support
Our top pick: Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C in one pad, mechanical keys with real heft, and a calculator mode that keeps working with the computer off.