Best Overall
Elgato 4K S
Key details
- HDR
- HDR10 with Windows tone mapping
- Connection
- USB-C 3.0
- Max Capture
- 4K60
- High Frame Rate
- 1440p120 / 1080p240
The question that decides a PS5 capture setup usually is not resolution. It is HDR. Leave HDR on with a cheap card and recordings come back washed out; turn it off and the console looks flat on your TV for the whole session. The 4K S is the card here that handles the handoff properly, capturing HDR10 with tone mapping on Windows so an HDR game lands on your drive looking like something you can post. That, more than any other single spec, is why it leads this list.
The capture ladder is generous: 4K60 to the PC, 1440p120 or 1080p240 for high-frame-rate games, and a passthrough that keeps the television's picture intact while you play. We were also pleased by the 3.5mm analog input. PS5 party chat does not travel down the HDMI cable, so a physical input is how your friends' voices reach the recording without a second mixer in the chain. It is a small port that solves a problem most cards here leave you to sort out yourself.
It is, however, the pickiest card of the group about the machine on the other end. The requirements are specific: Windows 11 64-bit or macOS 13, an 8th-gen Core i5 or an M1, and a real USB-C 3.0 port. The friction sits at setup rather than later, so plug it into the port it asks for instead of a hub shared with a webcam, and read the setup steps once before deciding anything is wrong.
For a PS5 on a 4K TV with a Windows desktop behind it, this is the least compromising route to recordings that hold up next to the console's own output, with HDR, high frame rates, and the chat input in one small box. Stream at 1080p60 and never touch HDR, and you are paying for headroom you will not use.
Pros
- 4K60 capture with HDR10 tone mapping
- 1440p120 and 1080p240 support
- 3.5mm input for chat or commentary
- Two-year manufacturer warranty
Cons
- HDR tone mapping is Windows-only
The one we point PS5 owners to when the recordings need to match what the console puts out: 4K60 capture, HDR tone mapping, and a passthrough that leaves your TV alone.