Best Overall
Elgato 4K S
Key details
- Connection
- USB-C (USB 3.0)
- Audio Input
- 3.5mm analog
- Passthrough
- 1440p120 / 1080p240
- Capture Resolution
- 4K60
The first thing we did with the 4K S was set it beside Elgato's flagship and work out what the extra money buys. For anyone streaming a PS5 or an Xbox Series X, the answer is not much. This card captures 4K at 60fps, passes 1440p at 120Hz or 1080p at 240Hz through to a fast monitor, and adds a 3.5mm input the flagship does not have. That combination is why it is our default pick rather than the pricier card.
Installation is one USB-C cable. The card turns up in OBS as a video source and a separate audio device with no driver to install, and at 90 grams it disappears into a laptop bag next to an HDMI lead. HDR10 capture works with tone mapping on Windows, so a bright game does not arrive in the recording looking washed out — a detail that matters more than frame rate once you start grading anything.
The 3.5mm jack is the part we keep coming back to. A mic runs straight into the card while game audio stays on the HDMI path, so a two-input stream does not need a mixer in front of it, and voice and game land on separate tracks to fix later. Elgato also lists iPadOS with USB-C, which means the card can feed a tablet and turn it into a field monitor for a camera.
It does want a current machine: Windows 11 or macOS 13, an 8th-gen Core i5 or better, and a USB-C port that is not already shared with three other devices. Get that right and the capture is clean, audio included, which is more than we can say for several cheaper cards in this group.
Pros
- 4K60 capture with high-refresh passthrough
- 3.5mm input for a mic or chat
- Bus-powered USB-C at 90 grams
- HDR10 capture with Windows tone mapping
Cons
- No HDMI 2.1 or VRR passthrough
For a console or a single gaming PC, this is the capture card we tell people to buy: 4K60 recording, high-refresh passthrough, and a mic input for a price that still leaves room for a decent microphone.